|| IP34320 |
|| THE ETHICS OF WAR IN THEORY AND PRACTICE |
|| 2007/2008 |
|| Dr Toni A Erskine |
|| Semester 1 |
| Course delivery
|| Lecture || 15 Hours. (15 x 1 hour) |
|| Seminars / Tutorials || 5 Hours. (5 x 1 hour) |
|Assessment Type||Assessment Length/Details||Proportion|
|Semester Assessment|| Essay: 1 x 3,000 words ||50%|
|Semester Exam||2 Hours ||50%|
|Supplementary Exam|| Students may, subject to Faculty approval, have the opportunity to resit this module, normally during the supplementary examination period. For further clarification please contact the Teaching Programme Administrator in the Department of International Politics.|| |
On completion of this module, students should be able to do the following:
- Discuss and distinguish between the different theoretical approaches employed to question the ethics of war.
- Identify the central principles associated with the Just War Tradition.
- Explain and compare the different ethical arguments used to justify these principles.
- Describe the practical problems faced by actors (individuals, military organizations, states, intergovernmental organizations) in adhering to these principles.
- Define what is meant by 'new wars' and contrast them with conventional wars.
- Critically evaluate the relevance of 'just war' principles to contemporary conflict.
- Illustrate responses to the previous three points with reference to contemporary and historical examples.
The ethics of war is a subject that has experienced a revival in the study of International Relations over the last thirty years. It is also a subject with immediate relevance. Statements addressing the justice of both the resort to force and conduct in its execution are prevalent in the media and in contemporary political debates. This course explores the moral arguments behind these statements and presents students with the opportunity to question them in relation to concrete events.
The aims of this module are the following: to introduce students to the central ethical debates surrounding the resort to force in international relations; and, to provide students with the knowledge and skills necessary to critically examine the moral arguments and categories invoked in these debates, to analyze how these arguments and categories might be affected by the changing nature of war, and to relate such an examination to contemporary and historical examples of organized violence.
The module will be divided into three parts. The first part will introduce students to the central theoretical frameworks employed in examining ethics and the use of force. Students will explore consequentialist and deontological justifications for actions as well as different approaches to the ethics of war (pacifism, 'feminist ethics', just war theory and the idea of 'total war'.) Specific attention will be given to the just war tradition. Mention will also be made of the role of different religions (Christianity, Islam and Judaism) in advocating and defining restraint in war.
In the second part of the module, students will apply these approaches and concepts to ethical debates surrounding practical problems. These will include the following: the ethics of civilian casualties, justifications for 'humanitarian intervention', and the relevance of just war categories in response to 'terrorist' attacks. Each issue will be discussed in the context of concrete examples. The third part of the module will involve students analyzing the implications of the changing nature of war on these debates. The category of 'new wars' will be explored, as will developments in military technology and the 'CNN factor', whereby media exposure means that public opinion arguably has an increasing influences conduct in war.
Restraint in War: Theoretical Perspectives
1: Introduction: Moral Thinking and War
2: Two Extremes: Pacifism and Unrestrained War
3: Restraint: Religious and Secular Approaches
The Just War Tradition
4: The Just War Tradition: History, Proponents and Critics
5: Jus Ad Bellum: The Justice of Going to War
6: Jus In Bello: Just Conduct in War
Interpretation and Controversy: Applying Just War Principles to Practice
7: `Anticipation' as a Justification for Going to War: Preventive Wars and Pre-emptive Strikes
8: Moral Arguments For and Against Nuclear Deterrence
9: `Supreme Emergencies': Justifiable Exceptions?
10: War Crimes and `Superior Orders': Who Should Be Held Responsible for Breaking the Rules of War?
New Challenges: The Ethics of War in the 21st Century
11: The Ethics of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism
12: `Humanitarian' Wars
13: Jus Post Bellum: Just and Unjust Occupations
14: Conclusion: `New Wars', New Combatants, New Threats and the Relevance of the Just War Tradition
I: Engaging in an `Anticipatory' War: The Second Gulf War
2: Targeting Civilians: Hiroshima, Nagasaki and the Bombing of German Cities during WWII
3: Who is Responsible for Obeying the Rules of War? The Massacre at My Lai
4: The Collection of Intelligence and the Treatment of Prisoners: Guantanamo Bay and Abu Ghraib
5: `Humanitarian' War? The Kosovo Campaign
6: Postwar Justice: The Occupation of Iraq
The students' ability to work independently on a project will be developed through planning, researching and writing an assessed essay. Students will be expected to word-process their essays with footnotes and a bibliography and encouraged to research their essay topics using computer databases at the library. IT skills will be encouraged by the students accessing the relevant course information using the software programme, 'Blackboard'.
Students will develop the ability to express themselves and present their work in front of a group in the context of responding to 'moral dilemmas' posed in seminars. They will be given feedback on their presentations by the seminar instructor. Both the seminars and the essay project will help students to develop a number of valuable, transferable skills. These include: team work, presentation skills, time-management, independent research, group planning and communication.
10 ECTS Credits
Brown, Chris (1992) International Relations Theory: New Normative Approaches - Chapter 4
Jackson, Robert The Global Covenant: Human Conduct in a World of States - chapters 9 & 10
Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000
Kaldor, Mary (1998) New & Old Wars: Organized Violence in a Global Era
Cambridge: Polity Press
This module is at CQFW Level 6